Newsgroups: comp.sys.atari.st
Path: utzoo!utgpu!jarvis.csri.toronto.edu!dgp.toronto.edu!juancho
From: juancho@dgp.toronto.edu (John Buchanan)
Subject: Re: Suspected GEMDOS bug or where did the disk sectors go?
Message-ID: <8805121345.AA14452@champlain.dgp.toronto.edu>
Organization: University of Toronto, CSRI
References: <2936@cognos.UUCP> <1058@atari.UUCP>
Date:	Thu, 12 May 88 08:25:00 EDT

In article <1058@atari.UUCP> good@atari.UUCP (Roy Good) writes:
>In article <2936@cognos.UUCP>, bdeskin@cognos.uucp (Bob Deskin) writes:
>> A week ago I posted a question about what happens to 2K when formatting a
>> floppy disk. [...deleted...]
>> I have since been told that this is an old GEMDOS bug where GEMDOS 
>> "loses" 2K or 4 sectors. [...deleted...]
>> Can anyone confirm this bug (Atari???) and is it fixed in the new ROMs. 
>
>It is an old GEMDOS problem, and it was fixed in an interim version of the
>forthcoming ROMs. However, the fix has been backed out due to potentially
>serious loss of data due to incompatibility problems when disks with the
	I for one would be pleased to reformat all my disks if you fix this.
I would not be to concerned about compatibility, rather more about 
correctness.  After all if we were concerned with compatibility we would 
still  be working with cards on a IBM machine.  (WHat a THOUght)

>-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
>Roy J. Good
	Keep up the good work.



=====================================================================
| Typical conversation on comp.[atari|amiga|mac].*		    |
=====================================================================
My watch is better than yours.  It has multitasking, windows and
plays Old macdonald has a farm.  I will not listen to reason, of
course your watch is not as good as mine, in fact you are
silly for having bought it.  Sell it and buy my kind.
   o /
====X================================================================
   o \
John W. Buchanan                  Dynamic Graphics Project
               			  Computer Systems Research Institute
(416) 978-6619			  University of Toronto
juancho@dgp.toronto.edu
juancho@toronto.CSNET
{allegra,cornell,decvax,ihnp4,linus,utzoo}!utdgp!juancho