Relay-Version: version B 2.10 5/3/83; site utzoo.UUCP
Posting-Version: version B 2.10.1 6/24/83; site ttidcb.UUCP
Path: utzoo!watmath!clyde!burl!ulysses!allegra!bellcore!decvax!mcnc!philabs!ttidca!ttidcb!robertsb
From: robertsb@ttidcb.UUCP
Newsgroups: net.politics
Subject: response to Gun Control advocates
Message-ID: <224@ttidcb.UUCP>
Date: Mon, 17-Dec-84 11:48:14 EST
Article-I.D.: ttidcb.224
Posted: Mon Dec 17 11:48:14 1984
Date-Received: Fri, 21-Dec-84 00:52:15 EST
Organization: TTI, Santa Monica, CA.
Lines: 126

On the subject of Gun Control, Mike Ryan writes:

>        Don Steiny made the claim that citizens kill more criminals
>than do police.  This was subsequently refuted by Jeff Shallit, but
>it's irrelevant anyway.  A more useful comparison would be between
>how many legal handgun killings (justifiable self-defense) and how
>many illegal handgun killings occur.  The FBI (you know them - the
>liberal pinko gun-control fanatics:-) reports that in 1983 157 criminals
>were killed by citizens, and there were 22,000 handgun fatalities in
>all.  That's a 140-1 ratio, folks.  Oh, but of course

	The point Mr. Steiny has here is that handguns do indeed have a
life-saving function. For those killings to have been legal the person
involved would have had to be in FEAR FOR THEIR LIFE OR THE LIFE OF ANOTHER.

>> The number wounded, captured, or driven off is far more important.

>Well, if you're going to count this, don't forget to count the number
>of handgun crimes committed in which the criminal does not kill anyone.
>I don't have the stats on this (and they're probably harder to count,
>seeing as deaths do tend to attract more attention), but it is safe
>to say that handguns are used illegally far more often then they are
>used legally.

	As a matter of FACT it is EASY to count the statistics if you don't
ignore them.
	300,000 Americans use a handgun EACH YEAR to either kill, wound,
arrest or scare away an assailent or burgler.
	.03% of firearms are ever used in any crime. Thus you are attempting
to control something where 99.97% are legally used. This clearly refutes
YOUR argument.


>        Robin has a point here about crime prevention.  However,
>the "neutral tool" in question is not meaningless.  It is one which
>significantly increases the damage done in crime.  Some crimes actually
>become impractical without guns (armed bank robbery, for instance). It's

	Not true, there have already been robberies using everything from
mace to "stun guns" to bombs both real and mockup. Further notice here the
big lie. Above he says he is only interested in controlling handguns but
ALL of his crime control arguments require complete control of ALL
firearms even if you blindly accept his logic. Thus we see that this truely
is an assault on the entire 2nd amendment as a whole for they will INDEED
next say that rifles and shotguns are to be controlled.

>interesting to note that the "need" for handguns decreases as crime
>decreases (if there's no crime, there's no need for a gun).
>Something should certainly be done about the crime problem, but private
>ownership of guns is no answer.


Private ownership of guns isn't suppose to be THE ANSWER, unlike the claims
YOU have for gun control but it is a function of my right to defense of my
life and liberty.
Further without ANY effect of crime rates you wish to make my defense less
efficient. You haven't the right to make me less safe and that is the only
real effect of your proposals.


>        Oh, there is one use for a handgun besides self-defense,
>and that's for sport (target-shooting).  This does not require private
>ownership of the guns; they can be owned by and stored at the
>facility at which they're used (which, needless to say, should
>be reasonably secure).  There's no reason for a sportsman to have
>a gun at home.

The only effect you have here is to restrict law abiding citizens and
we've already shown that as counter productive.

>Please do not call my opinions ignorant, silly, or ridiculous or
>my "sayings" or concepts cute - they are not the product of uninformed
>speculation and are (at least:-) as valid as yours.
>                Mike Ryan

I'm sorry Mr. Ryan but they are the product of uninformed speculation
because they don't conform to reality and they DO attempt to treat symptoms
instead of diseases. Excuse me while a shoot down another ignorant argument:

>From: mfs@mhuxr.UUCP (SIMON)

>> > There is a poster on my door.  It reads <....>
>>
>> What a fascinating example of propaganda. What about the
>> countrys that have low handgun death statistics but
>> don't have handgun control? What about the overall crime
>> rates in these countrys, and the differences between them.
>> Are you over simplifying or did you just choose to ignore
>> any statistics that didn't support your opinion.
>>
>Can YOU (Fader) list any countries that have no handgun control
>AND low handgun death statistics?? The fact is that a hell of a lot
>of people die of handgun shots in the US because there is a hell of a lot
>of handguns in the US. Anti-handgun regulation people cannot escape that.
>
>Marcel Simon                    ..!mhuxr!mfs

How about me Mr. Simon?
First the poster IS blatant propaganda as it doesn't give populations from
which we can derive rates, a more useful statistical FACT.

Second it has a line of which I am quite fond ( I love using their OWN
numbers to refute them.  Tee Hee ). It quotes 24 handgun deaths in Israel.
Have you been to Israel or spoken to a resident of Israel, Mr. Simon?
The people their are armed to a much HIGHER degree than ourselves and
rightfully so. Believe me it is a clear example of how little Handgun
Control Inc. understands the issue for them to list that country.

A closing FACT for you dear readers:
FBI statistics reveal that handgun ownership has risen 28% between 1974 and
1981 and handgun homicide has DROPPED 7% over the same percent.

A clear lack of correlation between handguns and crime. Treat diseases not
symptoms !!

-- 

    Robin D. Roberts                     (213) 450 9111 x 2916
    TTI     Zone V4                     aka Buskirk the Valerian
    3100 Ocean Park Blvd                    Death to Tyrants !
    Santa Monica, CA 90405

 UUCP: ..!ucbvax!ihnp4!vortex!ttidca!ttidcb!robertsb
 or  {cadovax,flick,philabs,randvax,trwrb,vortex,wtux2}!ttidca!ttidcb!robertsb
 or   ttidca!ttidcb!robertsb@RAND-UNIX.ARPA