Megalextoria
Retro computing and gaming, sci-fi books, tv and movies and other geeky stuff.

Home » Sci-Fi/Fantasy » The X-Files » CSM is the daddy - En Ami is the proof
Show: Today's Messages :: Show Polls :: Message Navigator
E-mail to friend 
Switch to threaded view of this topic Create a new topic Submit Reply
CSM is the daddy - En Ami is the proof [message #404385] Sat, 13 January 2018 15:26 Go to next message
Anonymous
Karma:
Originally posted by: embradine@gmail.com

I've come back from the future to tell you you were right.

Welcome next gen X-Philes.

Bernardine
Re: CSM is the daddy - En Ami is the proof [message #407693 is a reply to message #404385] Mon, 16 March 2020 15:00 Go to previous messageGo to next message
Anonymous
Karma:
Originally posted by: renancardosodossantos8563@gmail.com

https://www.cinemablend.com/television/1753699/the-x-files-c reator-already-debunked-a-season-11-theory-that-could-have-c hanged-everything
Re: CSM is the daddy - En Ami is the proof [message #414803 is a reply to message #404385] Sat, 18 June 2022 21:25 Go to previous message
Anonymous
Karma:
Originally posted by: nayane.amf@gmail.com

Em terça-feira, 23 de maio de 2000 às 04:00:00 UTC-3, Daniel Perez escreveu:
> The proof that CSM is the father of Scully's baby is encoded within the
> subtext of dialogue and action in "En Ami". Throughout the entire
> episode, while CSM was psychologically manipulating Scully for getting
> the disk containing the cancer cure, he obviously had fatherhood on his
> mind.
> --------------
> Exhibit A
> CSM cures the little boy of cancer, leaves a Goochland, Virginia paper
> on Scullys doorstep, distracts Mulder from the case with the fake
> e-mails and manipulates Scully into seeing the little boy who was cured
> of cancer the exact same way she was; with a chip in the back of the
> neck. Why? For the purpose of awakening deep feelings of motherhood
> within Scully.
> --------------
> Exhibit B.
> In the office building, CSM tells Scully that she's a "woman of
> compassion" and says the following;
> "In the end, a man finally looks at the sum of his life, to see what
> he'll leave behind. Most of what I've worked to build is in ruins.
> And now that the darkness descends, I find I have no real legacy"
> What does Smoking Man mean by "no real legacy"? That he has no one to
> carry out his wishes for the project to continue. CSM shot his son
> Jeffery Spender in "One Son" and we learned that Mulder is also CSM's
> son in "Amor Fati", but there's no way that Mulder would carry on CSM's
> work. Therfore CSM was longing for another chance to continue, even
> beyond death, and that would mean another son.
> --------------
> Exhibit C
> In the following exchange between CSM and Scully after CSM throws out
> his cigarettes while riding the Sedan, we see more evidence;
> CSM: No sacrifice is truly altruistic. We give, expecting to recieve.
> Scully: What exactly is it you expect to recieve?
> CSM: Your trust. You question my sincerity. You think I'm heartless.
> Would it soften your opinion of me if I confessed that I've always had
> particular affection for you?
> A sharp glance by Scully at CSM.
> CSM: I assure you my intentions are honorable. I have affection for
> Mulder too. My affection for you is special. I held your life in my
> hands. Your cancer was terminal and I had the cure. Can you imagine
> what that's like? To have the power to extinguish a life in order to
> save it and let it flourish? Now to give you that power, so you can do
> the same.
> Throughout this entire exchange of manipulating Scullys trust he
> confessed that he had a "particular" and "special" affection for her.
> "Particular" is defined as "distinctinve, special, fastidious", meaning
> that CSM was paying very close attention to Scully's life, possibly
> stalking her through is information channels. He also threw in the
> line "I have affection for Mulder too" in order to keep her from
> panicking and leaving. CSM also said his intentions are "honorable".
> Everything known about CSM tells us he is never to be trusted and that
> he doesn't know the meaning of the word "honorable".
> --------------
> Exhibit D
> The next day, the exchange in the Sedan between CSM and Scully
> continues;
> CSM: You've been at the wheel too long. Would you like me to drive?
> Scully: I might, if you let me know where we're going
> CSM: Knowing that, would you feel comfortable? You'd trust me? How
> long did it take Mulder to win your trust?
> Scully: I've always trusted Mulder.
> CSM: You're not being honest with yourself. Think back. There was a
> time when you feared for your future, for your career, when you were
> first parterned with this man. I've told you, I've studied you for
> years. And if you would permit me, I'd like to make an observation.
> You're drawn to powerful men, but you fear their power. You keep your
> guard up, a wall around your heart. How else you explain a fearless
> devotion to a man obsessed, and yet, a life alone. You'd die for
> Mulder, but you won't allow yourself to love him.
> Scully: Wow. I'm learning a whole other side to you. You're not just
> a cold blooded killer, you're pop psychologist as well.
> CSM: I've been a destroyer all my life. Before I die, I'd like to
> prove I'm capable of something more.
> Obviously CSM was stalking Scully when he said; "I've told you, I've
> studied you for years". CSM's observation that "Scully is drawn to
> powerful men, but fears their power" and that "she keeps her guard up,
> a wall around her heart" was CSM's wish for a relationship between him
> and Scully. All of CSM's other women are now dead or missing;
> Cassandra Spender, Teena Mulder and Diana Fowley. Therefore he
> pursued Scully as a last chance to continue his legacy, not with a
> cancer cure given to Scully, but with a son(or daughter).
> --------------
> Exhibit E
> When CSM and Scully visit the 118 year old Margarie Butters he refers
> to Scully in his introduction as "my very good friend".
> --------------
> Exhibit F
> When CSM and Scully finally arrive at the house in Milford,
> Pennsylvania, Scully is asleep in the passenger seat. CSM puts on a
> pair of gloves, possibly to remove traces of fingerprints. CSM looks at
> the sleeping Scully and gently moves the bangs of hair out of her face
> with with his fingers; he looks as if he wants to kiss her.
> --------------
> Exhibit G
> Scully wakes up in bed, shocked to find herself in a pair of pajamas
> and her clothes hanging in a closet. CSM has had a past history of
> taking Scully to a far away place and removing her clothes. We saw it
> in Fight the Future when Scully was taken to Antartica, stripped naked
> and packed into a cocoon to become an alien digestive. Scully begins
> to panic at the possibility that something happened.
> The next scene shows CSM offering Scully a cup of morning coffee as she
> storms toward the door to leave.
> CSM: How do you take your coffee.
> Scully: Unadulterated, thank you.
> Scully takes the coffee from CSM and dumps it out the window.
> Scully: You drugged me!
> CSM: I did nothing of the sort.
> Scully: How did the hell did I get out of my clothes and into bed?
> CSM: I carried you. You've been up for over 30 hours. You were
> delerious. I only wanted to make you comfortable.
> Scully: Where are we?
> CSM: Milford, Pennsylvania
> Scully: Well that wasn't part of the deal. I don't know what you're up
> to.
> We know from the previous exibits leading up to the "Scully waking up
> in pajamas scene" that CSM obviously impregnated Scully. Assuming that
> CSM was too ill from his disease to "perform", it's very possible that
> CSM had Scully impregnated by invitro fertilization with CSM's seed and
> one of Scully's missing eggs. When Scully is offered the coffee, she
> says "Unadulterated, thank you". "Adulterated" is defined as "adding
> undesirable ingredients to". By saying "unadulterated" Scully is
> saying she wants her coffee "undefiled" or "uncontaminated" unlike what
> she assumes happened to her during the night. The next exhibit backs
> up the impregnation scenario.
> --------------
> Exhibit H
> While at dinner, CSM explains the cancer cure science to Scully and the
> expected contact. In the course of that converstation he tell's Scully
> that he's a "lonely man", becomes emotional and leaves the room.
> CSM: That which makes miracles, can also make great evil There are
> those who would use this power for their own purposes. To choose who
> will live and who will die. Theoretically, I can be cured. Everything
> I've told you but wanting to make right. I'm a lonely man, Dana.
> CSM becomes emotional, gets up from the table.
> CSM: Excuse me.
> It's very possible that CSM had some deep feelings of guilt for having
> Scully impregnated bubble up inside of him, a man who has manipulated
> everything to his advantage, even his past relationships with Cassandra
> Spender, Teena Mulder and Diana Fowley. A obvious sign of an
> emotional split personality, with a dominant personality that's evil
> and destroys everything while having a second and lesser personality of
> longing and wanting to be normal and loved like everyone else. The two
> contrasting personalies twist the very soul of CSM into a pretzel.
> It was mentioned in another Usenet post that "En Ami" was a Monster of
> the Week Episode with CSM as the "monster". In a way, that
> description is right if you look at this episode from the point of view
> of the story about Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, split personalities within
> one man constantly at war with each other. The episode was described
> by William B. Davis as being inspired by Shakespeare's Richard III.
> Looking into the CSM/Scully impregnation scenario reveals that "En Ami"
> is a combination of Richard III with Jekyll & Hyde.
> -------------
> Exhibit I
> When CSM is outside the restaraunt, he talks to his henchman about
> Cobra, the contact with the cancer cure.
> CSM: Cobra hasn't shown.
> Henchman: What do you want to do?
> CSM: Wait. What else can we do?
> Henchman: What trust you won, Scully won't stick around forever.
> CSM looks away with a troubled look.
> Henchman: What's wrong?
> CSM: Just do your damn job.
> Obviously when the Henchman brought up the subjects of "trust" and
> "Scully" in the same sentence, it troubled CSM deeply. When the
> Henchman asked what was wrong, CSM told him to "do his damn job" to
> hide his feelings of guilt for impregnating Scully.
> -------------
> Exhibit J
> When Scully is sent to meet Cobra, Cobra is assassinated by CSM's
> henchman after Scully gets the disk. Scully almost meets a similar
> fate, but is saved when CSM kills the henchman. He was protecting his
> "legacy" that's now inside of Scully.
> --------------
> Exhibit K
> When Mulder and Scully check out the now abandoned office building
> their dialogue gives us more clues when they enter CSM's empty office.
> Scully: He was here! These were his offices! What the hell is this?
> Mulder: He used you.
> Scully: Mulder, he laid it all out for me. I recorded it. I mailed
> you the tape. This old woman Margarie Butters. I met her, I saw her
> pictures, her birth certificate....
> Mulder: You saw what you needed to see in order to make you believe.
> Scully: What about this boy? This boy with cancer? You can't deny
> that. That's undeniable proof.
> Mulder: Even if we could convince his parents to let us march him out,
> how long before that chip in his neck mysteriously dissappears. This
> was a perfectly executed con, Scully. The only thing I can't figure
> out is why you're still alive.
> Bingo, Mulder hit it on the head with out realizing it by saying "The
> only thing I can't figure out is why you're still alive". Because
> Scully is carrying CSM's baby. It gets more interesting.
> Scully: Mulder, I looked into his eyes. I swear what he told me was
> true.
> Mulder: He did it all for himself, to get the science on that disk.
> His sincerity was a mask, Scully. The man's motives never changed.
> Scully: You think he used me to save himself, at the expense of the
> human race.
> Mulder: He knows what that science is worth, how powerful it is. He'd
> let nothing stand in his way.
> Scully: You may be right. But for a moment I saw something else in
> him. A longing for something more than power, maybe for something he
> could never have.
> After Scully's last piece of dialogue, CSM throws the disk with the
> cancer cure into a lake and lights up a Morley, knowing that he has
> doomed himself to die in a few months. The lines spoken by Scully, "I
> swear what he told me was true", "you think he used me to save himself"
> and "I saw something else in him, a longing for something more than
> power. Maybe for something he never had" were subconscious clues of
> Scullys impregnation by CSM without Scully ever being aware of it.
> Conclusion?
> The only reason Scully smiled at the end of "Requiem" when she said
> "she's pregnant" is that she assumes the baby is Mulders. "Requiem" is
> defined as "service for the dead". CSM was murdered by Krycek.
> "Service for the dead" symbolizes CSM's impregnation of Scully. We
> now know that the dead CSM is the father and will be reborn like a
> phoenix through Scully.
> Yours truly
>
> Daniel Perez

I had this same theory, but I never thought it would be right, damn.
  Switch to threaded view of this topic Create a new topic Submit Reply
Previous Topic: Re: I.D. Cards - Opening Titles
Next Topic: Order of the Blessed St. Scully the Enigmatic, send me a tweet
Goto Forum:
  

-=] Back to Top [=-
[ Syndicate this forum (XML) ] [ RSS ] [ PDF ]

Current Time: Fri Mar 29 10:13:51 EDT 2024

Total time taken to generate the page: 0.12065 seconds